The Dark History of the Reincarnated Villainess Ep 8: Tropey, Cringe, But Unapologetically Fun

If you’re into otome isekai shows where the main character is supposed to be a villainess but accidentally becomes the hero, then Episode 8 of The Dark History of the Reincarnated Villainess is right up your alley. Titled “Original Is a Magical Set of Letters,” this episode dives into the creepy side of the series while staying true to the guilty-pleasure vibe that fans can’t get enough of.

First off, let’s recap the episode quickly (no major spoilers, promise!). The plot centers around Duchess Amaryllis—who’s revealed to be the mysterious Bloody Rosa, a kidnapper of beautiful girls. Our leads, Iana and Cheneau, team up to save Menoa (one of Amaryllis’s captives) but walk straight into a trap. They end up locked in her basement, which she calls an “insane paradise” for her prisoners. The tension here is palpable: you can feel their panic as they realize they’re stuck, and Amaryllis’s twisted belief that she’s doing good (even while holding people hostage) adds a dark, almost horror-like edge to the episode.

Now, let’s talk about what fans are saying. Over on MyAnimeList, this series is a hit among viewers who love the villainess trope. One fan summed it up perfectly: “These villainess anime are my guilty pleasure—I love how she’s failing at being a good villain without even realizing it.” And honestly, that’s the core of the show’s charm. The main character (Alicia, her reincarnated name) is supposed to be the evil villainess from an otome game, but her earnest attempts to be bad end up making her the most likable person in the series. She tries to be mean, but instead, she helps people and wins everyone over—classic “villainess fails at villainy” energy, and we’re here for it.

But not everyone is totally on board. Some fans have pointed out the animation flaws: one user noted, “Something looks off—maybe the head proportions or the visuals just feel cheap.” Another complained about the male characters being super generic: “The Duke gives off massive bland vibes, like a random low-budget isekai MC.” And let’s be real, the hair color = magic attribute trope is everywhere here—green for healing, blonde for light, red for fire… you get the idea. A fan joked, “This is so convenient, it’s almost lazy!” But even with these flaws, most viewers don’t care because the show is just fun. As one fan put it: “I don’t need peak anime quality here—I just love seeing my dumb villainess girls have a great time.”

Episode 8 specifically has some standout moments. The trap scene where Iana and Cheneau fall into Amaryllis’s basement is tense, and the way Amaryllis acts like she’s doing something noble (even though she’s kidnapping people) is both creepy and fascinating. Fans also loved the dynamic between Iana and Cheneau—their teamwork feels natural, and you root for them to escape. The plot twist (Amaryllis being Bloody Rosa) was a nice touch too—fans didn’t see that coming, and it adds a layer of mystery to the series.

Another common fan complaint is about the main character being too OP (overpowered). One user ranted: “She’s already too OP—her reading speed is insane, she can slice apples perfectly first try, and she does all that without even trying! Unlike Villainess Level 99, where being OP is the whole point, here it feels unearned.” But others argue that her OPness is part of the humor—she’s supposed to be a villainess, so her skills make sense in that context.

And let’s not forget the elephant in the room: the prince. A lot of fans find him creepy, especially his interactions with the young MC. One user said: “The prince gives off major creep vibes—smiling at a 7-year-old like that is not okay.” It’s a valid point, and it’s something that might make some viewers uncomfortable, but it’s also part of the show’s over-the-top nature.

But even with these issues, the show’s charm shines through. Episode 8’s ending (with Iana and Cheneau trapped) leaves viewers wanting more, which is exactly what a good episode should do. For young viewers who love anime that’s easy to watch and doesn’t require too much thinking, this series is perfect. It’s full of humor, drama, and just enough creepiness to keep you hooked. Whether you’re into isekai, villainess stories, or just looking for something to binge on the weekend, The Dark History of the Reincarnated Villainess is worth your time.

So, grab your snacks, sit back, and enjoy the chaos—because this villainess isn’t going to stop failing at being evil anytime soon. And honestly, we wouldn’t have it any other way. If you’re new to the series, start from the beginning to get the full context, but Episode 8 is a great taste of what the show has to offer. Trust me—you’ll be hooked in no time.

Final thought: This episode (and the series) is a reminder that sometimes, the best anime aren’t the ones with perfect animation or complex plots—they’re the ones that make you laugh, cringe, and keep coming back for more. And that’s exactly what The Dark History of the Reincarnated Villainess does. Go give it a watch!